• BLOG

MNV Holdings v. 200 South, 2021 UT App 76 (July 9, 2021)

This case involved whether a plaintiff could use different routes across the defendant’s land to prove a prescriptive easement claim. The plaintiff argued that it used three routes continuously during that time, but the district court held that the plaintiff…

Diversified Concepts LLC v. Koford, 2021 UT App 71 (July 1, 2021)

Outcome of an appeal in District Court. On interlocutory appeal, the court of appeals articulated a new framework and provided a detailed outline for how district courts should analyze spoliation claims. Where there is an allegation of  spoliation, the district court should first determine whether the custodial party violated its duty to preserve the evidence at issue.

Utah Rules of Civil Procedure

Justice Petersen issued a concurring opinion raising the question of whether the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure should permit judgment creditors to execute against claims in which they are defendants and then extinguish those claims, noting that the rules currently do allow for this practice. Justices Durrant and Himonas joined in the concurrence.

doTERRA Int’l, LLC v. Kruger, 2021 UT 24 (July 1, 2021)

In this personal injury action, the district court concluded that Utah law does not permit waiver of punitive damages prior to the injury. Affirming under a different rationale, the supreme court held that, as a matter of first impression, even…

In re Estate of D.A. Osguthorpe, 2021 UT 23 (July 1, 2021)

In this estate dispute, the district court granted a motion to dismiss appellant’s claim for intentional interference with inheritance finding that Utah law did not recognize that claim. In reversing the order, the supreme court held that Utah law recognizes…